Will Afghan "surge" be a success?

Discussion between:

"Joining me to discuss this topic are Thomas Donnelley, director of the Center for Defense Studies at the American Enterprise Institute. He worked with a group of military experts to develop the strategy for a military surge in Iraq. Matthew Hoh, served as a marine captain in Iraq. In 2009 he went to Afghanistan as a civilian political officer. He resigned later that year protesting continued U.S. involvement in what he termed a 35-year-old civil war. Andrew Exum, a fellow with the center for a New American Security. He served as an army captain in Afghanistan. He's helped assess the current strategy there as a civilian advisor to General Stanley McChrystal, the U.S. commander of coalition forces in Afghanistan. The topic this week, the surge in Afghanistan. Can the U.S. use the same playbook it used in Iraq?"